Contesting a will in Victoria usually means a family provision claim under Part IV of the Administration and Probate Act 1958: an eligible person, such as a spouse, domestic partner or child, asks the court for adequate provision from an estate that left them out or short. Claims must generally be commenced within six months of the grant of probate or letters of administration. We act for claimants and executors.

In this article
- Two different ways to "contest" a will
- Who can bring a Part IV claim?
- What does the court weigh?
- How long do I have to make a claim?
- How do these claims usually resolve?
- How does an executor defend an estate against a claim?
- What is a claim like in practice?
- How can I reduce the risk of a claim on my own will?
- What should you do now?
- Common questions
Two different ways to "contest" a will
People use one phrase for two distinct challenges. A validity challenge says the will itself should not stand: the will-maker lacked testamentary capacity, was unduly influenced, did not know and approve the contents, or the document was forged or improperly signed. If it succeeds, an earlier will governs instead, or the intestacy rules if there is none. A family provision claim accepts the will is valid but says it fails to make adequate provision for someone the deceased had a responsibility to provide for. Most "contesting" in Victoria is the second kind, under Part IV of the Administration and Probate Act 1958. Our guide to fraudulent calumny in Victoria explains a less familiar way a will's validity may be challenged, where the will-maker was told lies about the person left out.
Who can bring a Part IV claim?
Victoria confines claims to defined categories of "eligible person", including:
- a spouse or domestic partner at the date of death;
- children and stepchildren of any age, and anyone the deceased treated as their own child who for a substantial period believed the deceased was their parent;
- a former spouse or partner who could have brought family law proceedings but had not finalised them;
- a registered caring partner, a grandchild, a member of the deceased's household, and the spouse or domestic partner of a child of the deceased where that child dies within a year of the deceased's death.
Anyone in that last group must also show they were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased. Adult children face an additional statutory focus on their need and capacity to provide for themselves. Eligibility is a firm threshold, so friends, siblings and carers outside the categories cannot claim, however deserving. A careful will therefore starts by working out who could claim.
What does the court weigh?
The court asks whether, at the time of death, the deceased had a moral duty to provide for the claimant, and whether the will or the intestacy rules fail to make adequate provision for their proper maintenance and support, a question generally judged at the time of the hearing. The factors are practical: the size of the estate; the claimant's financial resources, health and earning capacity; the nature and length of the relationship; contributions the claimant made to the estate or the deceased's welfare; provision made during life; any conduct or estrangement; competing claims of beneficiaries; and the deceased's reasons, where they can be shown. A written statement of reasons left with the will is not decisive, but a considered one carries real weight.
How long do I have to make a claim?
A Part IV claim must generally be commenced within six months of the grant of probate or letters of administration. The court can extend time where it considers that appropriate, but only on an application made before the estate is finally distributed. An extension is the exception, so do not plan on one. Because an executor who has had no notice of a claim is generally protected if they distribute after the window closes, delay can empty the estate you are claiming against. If you think you may have a claim, find out this week whether probate has been granted and on what date, because the six months run from that date.
Do you believe the will of someone close to you has not provided adequately for you, and are you unsure whether probate has been granted? Your first call is free, and you speak with a lawyer. Call (03) 9125 8355 or send an enquiry.
How do these claims usually resolve?
Most of these claims settle without a trial. The Supreme Court generally refers family provision claims to mediation, and many resolve there. Settlements are struck as deeds or consent orders and can restructure gifts, create life interests or reallocate percentages. On costs, a successful claimant's reasonable costs are often paid from the estate, but an unsuccessful or overreaching claimant can be ordered to pay costs personally, so it is no longer safe to assume the estate always pays.
How does an executor defend an estate against a claim?
Executors served with a claim take on a defined role: remain even-handed, protect the estate, gather the evidence of the deceased's reasons and the beneficiaries' circumstances, and negotiate sensibly where the claim has substance. Distributing early on notice of a claim exposes the executor personally; so does running an unwinnable defence out of loyalty. We act for executors as well as claimants, and the judgment calls are mirror images. Our guide to an executor's duties covers the wider role. A will dispute has no fixed fee, so once we understand what you need, we set out a written fee estimate in a costs agreement before any substantive work begins. Your first call is free, and you speak with a lawyer.
What is a claim like in practice?
Expect an early exchange of written evidence about finances and relationships, then a mediation, to which the Supreme Court generally refers these claims and where many of them end. Throughout, the decisions are as much commercial as legal, weighing the strength of the claim against the certainty of settlement and the size of the estate against the cost of fighting over it. Emotions run high on both sides of a will dispute, and part of our work is turning a sense of grievance into a clear plan. Claimants are best placed when they get advice early, set out their circumstances honestly and let the merits of the claim, rather than anger, set the pace.
How can I reduce the risk of a claim on my own will?
No will can remove the right to bring a Part IV claim, and you cannot contract your family out of the Act. Careful planning does reduce the risk, through honest provision where a moral duty plainly exists, a written record of your reasons for treating people unequally, and deliberate use of assets that pass outside the estate, such as superannuation and jointly owned property. Where conflict is foreseeable, a testamentary trust can be used to make genuine provision for someone who might otherwise bring a claim. Read our guide to making a valid will, then talk it through with us rather than leaving it to the Supreme Court.
What should you do now?
If you have been left out of a will or left short, the six months from the grant are the deadline that matters, so find out now whether probate has been granted and when. If you are an executor, the same six months generally tell you when it is safe to distribute, provided you have had no notice of a claim. Either way, most of these disputes end in a settlement, and how well you have prepared shapes its terms. For the court's own explanation of probate and family provision claims, the Supreme Court of Victoria website is the place to start.
Common questions
How long do I have to contest a will in Victoria?
A Part IV claim must generally be commenced within six months of the grant of probate or letters of administration. The court can extend time where it considers that appropriate, but only on an application made before the estate is finally distributed. An extension is the exception, so do not plan on one.
Who can contest a will in Victoria?
Only an eligible person can make a family provision claim in Victoria. Eligible people include a spouse or domestic partner at the date of death, children and stepchildren of any age, and a former spouse or partner who could have brought family law proceedings but had not finalised them. A registered caring partner, a grandchild or a member of the deceased's household can also claim, but the court can make an order for them only if they were wholly or partly dependent on the deceased. Friends, siblings and carers outside those categories cannot claim, however deserving.
Do I have to go to court to contest a will?
A family provision claim is made by applying to the court, but most claims settle without a trial. The Supreme Court generally refers family provision claims to mediation, and many resolve there.
Who pays the legal costs of a family provision claim?
A successful claimant's reasonable costs are often paid from the estate, but an unsuccessful or overreaching claimant can be ordered to pay costs personally. It is no longer safe to assume the estate always pays.
Have you been left out of a will or left short, or are you an executor facing a claim? A claim must generally be made within six months of the grant. Your first call is free, and you speak with a lawyer. Call (03) 9125 8355 or send an enquiry.
Sources: Administration and Probate Act 1958 (Vic), Part IV, sections 90, 91, 91A, 94, 99 and 99A.
This guide reflects the law applying in Victoria as at November 2026. It is general information only, not legal advice, and does not take your circumstances into account.
